Overall, it looks like it may be heading for defeat. If it passes, it will be a very close thing, proving that it lacks widespread support (the bishops are fairly united in favor, but clergy and laity are less enthused). This turn of events has given rise to considerable comment
The letter from Diarmaid MacColluch to the Church Times is priceless.
As momentum against builds, the forces in support continue to marshal lame arguments in support.
- From the Bishops of Bristol and Oxford. Tobias Haller’s response.
- the Archbishop of Canterbury has issued a video in support (surely a sign of growing desperation)
- other essays in support linked from Thinking Anglicans
Diarmaid MacCulloch’s video response to the ABC:
Mark Harris on the “scramble for votes”
All this suggests increasing desperation on the side of the covenant’s supporters. Indeed, it’s hard to imagine the effects to the Anglican Communion’s leadership if it isn’t approved by the Church of England General Synod–and for it to be debated there it needs a majority of yes votes from the dioceses. It’s clear that its primary constituency in the CoE is the bishops. They support it overwhelmingly, while both the laity and clergy are split narrowly between supporters and opponents. Hopefully, the close votes in CoE diocesan synods will allow many who are somewhat swayed by the lame arguments of the ABC et al, to resist whatever “bonds of affection” they may feel, to resist the temptation to submit to the leadership’s requests.